Q (1 mark). In which pair do both species have the same shape?
A BF₃ and NF₃
B CO₂ and SO₂
C SiH₄ and BF₄⁻
D H₂O and BeCl₂
Model answer
C — SiH₄ and BF₄⁻ each have 4 bonding pairs and no lone pair on the central atom, so both are tetrahedral (109.5°).
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (1 mark):
- C ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2. Every other pair mixes a species with a lone pair on the central atom and one without: NF₃ is pyramidal (BF₃ planar), SO₂ is bent (CO₂ linear) and H₂O is non-linear (gaseous BeCl₂ linear). Candidates who match formula types (XY₃, XY₂) rather than counting lone pairs choose A, B or D.