Q (1 mark). The table gives data for four solids.
| solid | melting point / °C | conducts when solid? | conducts when molten? |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 801 | no | yes |
| B | 1083 | yes | yes |
| C | 114 | no | no |
| D | 1710 | no | no |
Which solid has a giant ionic structure?
Model answer
A — high melting point, and it conducts only when molten, when the ions are free to move.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (1 mark):
- A ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2 — deduce structure from given properties. The deciding evidence is the change from non-conducting (solid) to conducting (molten). B conducts as a solid, so it is metallic; D has a high melting point but never conducts, so it is giant covalent — the commonest wrong answer from candidates who look only at melting point.