Q (1 mark). Which compound gives a silver mirror when warmed with Tollens' reagent and a yellow precipitate when warmed with alkaline aqueous iodine?
A propanal
B ethanal
C propanone
D butanone
Model answer
B — ethanal, CH₃CHO, is an aldehyde (silver mirror) and contains CH₃CO– (the carbonyl carbon carries a methyl group), so it also forms CHI₃.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (1 mark):
- B ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2 — applying two tests at once. Propanal is an aldehyde but has CH₃CH₂CO–, not CH₃CO–; propanone and butanone give CHI₃ but, as ketones, do not reduce Tollens' reagent. Candidates who think 'the iodine test is for ketones' reject ethanal and lose the mark.