(a) In both models benzene is a planar regular hexagon of six carbons with H atoms at each vertex, every carbon sp² hybridised, C–C–C = H–C–C = 120°, and 12 σ bonds (six C–C in the ring plus six C–H). The two models differ only in what happens to the six unhybridised p orbitals: the Kekulé structure localises them into three C=C π bonds, while the modern model has them overlap sideways to give one delocalised π system holding six electrons over the whole ring.
(b) Evidence 1 — bond lengths. All six C–C bonds in benzene are the SAME length, 0.139 nm, intermediate between a single (0.154 nm) and a double (0.134 nm) bond. The Kekulé structure predicts two different bond lengths, so the delocalised model — in which each C–C bond has the same partial double-bond character — fits the data.
Evidence 2 — hydrogenation enthalpies. Three isolated cyclohexene C=C bonds would predict ΔH = 3 × −120 = −360 kJ mol⁻¹. Benzene actually releases only −208 kJ mol⁻¹, so it lies +152 kJ mol⁻¹ lower in enthalpy than the Kekulé structure. This 'missing' heat is the aromatic stabilisation of the delocalised π system.
(c) Addition would convert two ring carbons from sp² to sp³ and break the delocalised π ring, costing the 152 kJ mol⁻¹ of aromatic stabilisation calculated in (b). Substitution replaces only an H atom and, after loss of H⁺ from the intermediate, restores the aromatic system. The delocalised π system therefore makes substitution far more favourable than addition.