What an A* actually requires — accuracy over length
Top grades reward precise, controlled French, not just more words.
Many capable candidates believe the route to an A* is to write more — longer sentences, rarer words, bigger paragraphs. The mark schemes tell a different story. At the top of every 0520 paper, the deciding factor is accuracy and control: getting the small things right, consistently.
A typical Paper 4 (Writing) task is marked on two things at once:
- Communication / content — did you cover the task and the bullet points clearly?
- Language / accuracy — are your verbs, agreements, accents and structures correct?
A student who writes a short, correct answer that covers every bullet point will usually beat a student who writes a long, ambitious answer riddled with agreement and accent errors. The lesson: be ambitious, then be careful. Stretch your range, then check it.
The pitfalls in this note are the ones examiner reports flag year after year. None of them require new vocabulary to fix — they require habits: agreement checks, accent checks, reading the question twice, and proof-reading.
Worked mini-example — same idea, two grades.
- B-grade sentence: Ma soeur est content et elle a mange une pizza. (Several errors: missing accents on sœur nuance, content not agreeing, mangé missing its accent.)
- A*-grade sentence: Ma sœur est contente et elle a mangé une pizza. (My sister is happy and she ate a pizza.) Same vocabulary — the only difference is accuracy.
- A* = accurate and controlled French, not the longest answer.
- Paper 4 marks content (task coverage) AND language (accuracy) together.
- A short correct answer often outscores a long error-filled one.
- Every pitfall here is fixed by a habit, not by new vocabulary.