The obvious answer is that it must be bad. A leftward shift of the supply curve means less is produced and sold, and a producer who sells fewer units has fewer units to earn money on. If the fall came from a drought, a disease outbreak or a rise in input costs, the producer is also bearing the cause of it directly — ruined crops or higher bills — so the loss is doubled.
But the diagram shows something the intuition misses: a leftward shift raises the price. Producers sell less, but they sell it for more, so the effect on revenue is not obvious at all — it is a race between a smaller quantity and a higher price, and which wins depends on the price elasticity of demand.
Where demand is inelastic, the price rises proportionately more than the quantity falls, so total revenue increases. Producers are collectively better off after a fall in supply than before it. This is not a curiosity: it is the normal situation in agriculture, where demand for staple foods is inelastic because people must eat and there is no close substitute. A good harvest, by contrast, pushes supply right, collapses the price, and can leave farmers worse off despite having produced more — which is why bumper harvests are so often bad news for the farmers who produce them.
Where demand is elastic, the picture reverses. The price rise drives away a proportionately larger number of customers, revenue falls, and producers lose on both counts. This is typical of goods with close substitutes or luxuries, where consumers can simply buy something else.
The distribution of the effect matters too, and it usually differs from the aggregate. A fall in supply caused by some producers being wiped out is very bad for them and may be excellent for the survivors, who face a higher price without having lost any output. Talking about "producers" as a single group hides the fact that the loss and the gain often fall on different people.
My judgement is that a fall in supply is not always bad for producers, and the test is the price elasticity of demand for the good. Where it is inelastic, a fall in supply raises producers' revenue and is often positively beneficial to those who survive it; where it is elastic, it harms them on both price and quantity.
That also explains behaviour that would otherwise look irrational — why producers of agricultural commodities and oil so often organise to restrict their own supply. They are not making a mistake. With inelastic demand, producing less collectively earns more, and the only obstacle is that each individual producer has an incentive to break the agreement and sell more at the higher price.