Multiple choice: which good has the most inelastic demand
Which of the following goods is likely to have the most price-inelastic demand?
A A particular brand of chocolate bar
B Foreign holidays
C Prescription medicine for a serious illness
D Restaurant meals [1]
- 1
Recall the main determinant. Demand is inelastic when there are few close substitutes and the good is a necessity that cannot easily be postponed or given up.
- 2
Eliminate the distractors. A particular brand of chocolate (A) has many close substitutes — other brands — so its demand is highly elastic. Foreign holidays (B) and restaurant meals (D) are luxuries that can be postponed entirely, so demand for both is elastic.
- 3
Select C. Medicine for a serious illness has no substitute and cannot be given up, so the quantity demanded changes very little however the price moves.
Answer
C — prescription medicine for a serious illness.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: the availability of close substitutes is the single most important determinant of PED, and it is usually enough to answer questions of this type on its own. If a consumer can easily buy something else instead, demand is elastic; if they cannot, it is inelastic.
Note how narrowly the good is defined, because it changes the answer. Demand for chocolate in general is fairly inelastic — there is no close substitute for chocolate — while demand for one brand of chocolate is highly elastic, because every other brand is a near-perfect substitute. The same reasoning makes demand for petrol inelastic and demand for petrol from one particular station elastic.
Common mistake: assuming expensive goods have inelastic demand because people must pay a lot for them. The opposite is usually true — the larger the share of income a good absorbs, the more carefully consumers reconsider when its price rises, so demand tends to be more elastic.