PED is the right tool for the question and answers it directly. Revenue is price multiplied by quantity, and PED is precisely the ratio between the percentage change in quantity and the percentage change in price — so it tells you which of the two effects dominates. If PED is below 1, raising price raises revenue; if above 1, it lowers it. No other single number does this job, and a firm without it is guessing.
But a PED value is an estimate, and usually one drawn from the past. It is calculated from how consumers behaved when prices last changed, and those conditions do not repeat exactly. A firm applying yesterday's coefficient to tomorrow's decision is assuming a stability that markets rarely have.
The most important omission is that PED describes how consumers respond, and says nothing about how rivals will. A firm cutting its price by 10% may calculate that elastic demand will raise its revenue — and find that every competitor matches the cut within a week, so it gains almost no extra customers while receiving less for each one. The PED figure was correct as a description of consumer behaviour and useless as a prediction, because it assumed everything else stayed still.
PED also assumes nothing else changes, and in practice several things do. Incomes move, tastes shift, substitutes change price, seasons turn. Any of these shifts the whole demand curve, and a shift changes quantity at every price — which PED, a measure of movement along a curve, cannot capture at all.
The time period is a further problem. Demand is more elastic in the long run than in the short run, so a single PED figure is only valid over the horizon it was measured across. A firm that uses a short-run estimate to predict revenue over several years will be systematically wrong in a predictable direction.
And revenue is not the objective in any case. A firm cares about profit, which depends on costs as well. Cutting price may raise revenue and still reduce profit, if the extra units cost more to produce than they bring in.
My judgement is that PED is necessary but not sufficient, and the distinction matters because the two are often confused. Without it a firm cannot even work out the direction in which revenue will move, so it is indispensable. With it alone, a firm is assuming rivals will not react, that no determinant of demand will change, that the estimate still holds, and that revenue is what it is trying to maximise — four assumptions, any of which can fail.
The sensible use of PED is therefore as the starting point of the analysis rather than the whole of it: work out what the coefficient implies, then ask what rivals will do, what else is changing, over what period the decision is meant to hold, and what the extra output will cost. A firm that treats the PED calculation as the answer has done the first step and stopped.