Whose objectives come first?
Nova Textiles (NT)
Nova Textiles (NT) is a public limited company that manufactures clothing. Its main factory employs 320 people in a small town where NT is the largest employer.
NT's shareholders have complained that profit has fallen for two years running. Last year NT made a net profit of $1.4 million, down from $2.1 million.
The directors are considering closing the factory and moving production to another country, where wages are about 60% lower. This would save an estimated $900 000 a year.
The local government has offered NT a grant of $300 000 to stay, and has warned that 320 job losses would badly affect the town.
NT's marketing manager says: "Our customers like that our clothes are made locally. Two of our largest retail customers ask us about working conditions every year."
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to NT of making profit maximisation its main objective.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of NT. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three courses of action for NT. Which should NT choose? Justify your answer.
- •Close the factory and relocate production abroad
- •Stay, accept the grant, and cut costs within the existing factory
- •Relocate part of production and keep a smaller local factory
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Higher profit satisfies shareholders and supports the share price
NT's shareholders have complained after profit fell from $2.1 million to $1.4 million
- Application:
Profit provides retained earnings to reinvest
the $900 000 annual saving could fund new equipment or expansion for NT
- Application:
It gives managers a single clear target to work towards
useful for NT's directors after two years of decline
- Application:
It can damage relations with employees
320 NT workers would lose their jobs if the factory closed
- Application:
It can harm the firm's reputation with customers
NT's customers value locally made clothes, and two large retail customers ask about working conditions each year
- Application:
It can create conflict with the local community and government
the local government has offered NT $300 000 to stay and warned about the effect on the town
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: Profit maximisation satisfies shareholders (1). NT's shareholders have complained about profit falling from $2.1 million to $1.4 million, so raising profit would address their main concern (1 app).
Advantage 2: Higher profit provides funds for reinvestment (1). The $900 000 a year NT would save could be used to buy new equipment or expand (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: It can damage relations with employees (1). Closing the factory would cost 320 NT workers their jobs in a town where NT is the largest employer (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: It can harm reputation with customers (1). NT's customers value that its clothes are made locally, and two of its largest retail customers ask about working conditions every year (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Close the factory and relocate production abroad
For
Saves about $900 000 a year, more than reversing the $700 000 fall in profit
Directly addresses the shareholders' complaint
Wages abroad are roughly 60% lower, a lasting cost advantage
Against
320 employees lose their jobs and the town loses its largest employer
Customers value locally made clothes, so sales could fall
Two major retail customers audit working conditions and may withdraw
NT forfeits the $300 000 government grant
Stay, accept the grant, and cut costs within the existing factory
For
The $300 000 grant is immediate and unconditional on relocation
Keeps the 320 jobs, protecting NT's reputation with customers and the community
Retains the "made locally" selling point the marketing manager values
Avoids the disruption and risk of moving production abroad
Against
$300 000 is only a third of the $900 000 that relocating would save
It is a one-off grant, while the wage saving would recur every year
Shareholders may still be dissatisfied if profit does not recover
Cost cutting inside the factory may be limited and could hurt morale
Relocate part of production and keep a smaller local factory
For
Captures part of the wage saving while keeping some local jobs
NT can still describe some production as local for marketing
Reduces the scale of redundancies and community damage
Against
Running two sites raises management and transport costs, eroding the saving
The local government may refuse the $300 000 grant for a partial commitment
Customers may see partial relocation as misleading if products are still marketed as locally made
Some redundancies still occur, so employee relations are still damaged
Model recommendation
NT should stay, accept the grant and cut costs within the existing factory.
NT is a clothing business whose customers value local production, so the reputation at stake is not a side issue — it is part of what NT sells. Two of its largest retail customers audit working conditions annually, and losing either would cut revenue by more than the $900 000 relocation saves. Staying also secures the $300 000 grant and protects 320 jobs.
I rejected full relocation because the $900 000 saving is calculated on costs alone and ignores the revenue side. If customers and major retail buyers respond as the marketing manager suggests, NT could save $900 000 and lose more than that in sales.
I rejected partial relocation because it captures only part of the saving while adding the cost of running two sites, and risks the grant as well as the accusation of misleading marketing.
This depends on NT finding real savings inside the existing factory. If it cannot, shareholders will remain unhappy and the question will return next year — so the grant should be spent on productivity improvements rather than absorbed into profit.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to NT specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
NT employs 320 people and is the town's largest employer
- •
net profit fell from $2.1 million to $1.4 million
- •
shareholders have complained about two years of falling profit
- •
relocating would save about $900 000 a year on wages roughly 60% lower
- •
the local government has offered a $300 000 grant to stay
- •
two large retail customers ask about working conditions every year
- •
customers value that the clothes are made locally
- •
NT is a public limited company
Examiner tip
Stakeholder questions are marked on conflict, not on lists. Saying "employees want job security" is generic; saying "NT's 320 employees want job security but its shareholders want the $900 000 saving, and the directors cannot satisfy both" is application and analysis. In part (b), the strongest answers notice that a cost saving is not the same as a profit increase, because revenue may fall too.