Option 2, the supplier contract, is the option FW should choose.
Dami's stated objective is to increase profit, and Option 2 acts directly on the largest lever FW has. Fruit is a bought-in material, so a 15% reduction in its cost raises the added value on every bottle FW already sells, without needing to sell a single extra one. The benefit arrives immediately and continues for two years, and it requires no increase in output, no new staff and no additional loan repayments. For a business already carrying a $40 000 loan on its existing presses, an improvement in margin that creates no new fixed commitment is particularly valuable.
Option 1 is rejected because extra capacity only raises profit if the additional juice can be sold. FW's presses are the constraint on output, but nothing in the case suggests demand is going unmet, and a third press would add depreciation and probably further borrowing on top of the existing loan. Producing 50% more juice that sits unsold would worsen FW's position, not improve it.
Option 3 is rejected because it addresses a constraint FW is not currently hitting. Training the other three staff would make the business more flexible and reduce the risk of being unable to operate if a trained operator is absent — a genuine benefit — but it does not increase the margin on a bottle or the number of bottles sold. It is a sensible operational safeguard rather than a route to higher profit.
This recommendation rests on the objective being profit. If Dami's priority were growth in market share, Option 1 would become the stronger choice, since capacity would then be the binding constraint; and if her main concern were the risk of relying on only three trained operators, Option 3 would move ahead of both.