The business should not move entirely to performance-related pay, though it could add a performance element to a guaranteed basic salary.
The case for the change is real. Linking pay to performance gives every employee a direct financial reason to work productively, which a fixed salary does not — under a salary, the employee who works hardest and the one who does least are paid identically, which is both inefficient and unfair to the better worker. It also helps retain the strongest performers, who can see their effort reflected in their earnings, and lets the business's wage costs move with what it earns.
There are serious objections. Individual performance is difficult to measure fairly in most jobs: output is easy to count on a production line but not for someone in customer service, administration or design, and measuring the wrong thing produces the wrong behaviour — an employee paid for the number of calls handled will end calls quickly rather than solve problems. Rewarding individuals also discourages cooperation, since helping a colleague takes time that no longer counts towards one's own pay, and it can produce a workforce that competes rather than works together. Removing the security of a fixed salary creates anxiety, which Maslow's argument suggests will undermine motivation rather than raise it, and factors outside the employee's control — a quiet month, a supplier failure — can cut earnings through no fault of theirs.
The decisive consideration is whether performance can be measured accurately. Where it can, performance-related pay works well and the objections weaken considerably. Where it cannot, the business ends up rewarding whatever is measurable rather than whatever is valuable, which produces worse performance than the salary it replaced.
I therefore reject a complete move, because the risk is asymmetric: a poorly designed scheme does not simply fail to motivate, it actively distorts behaviour and damages cooperation, whereas a fixed salary merely fails to reward extra effort. Keeping a guaranteed basic salary and adding a performance element captures most of the incentive while preserving the security employees need — and the business should begin with roles where output is genuinely measurable rather than applying it to everyone at once.