Motivating drivers and reducing kitchen turnover
Verde Foods (VF)
Verde Foods (VF) is a private limited company that prepares fresh meals and delivers them to customers' homes. It was set up four years ago and now operates in three cities.
VF employs 25 kitchen staff and 12 delivery drivers. Kitchen staff are paid a wage of $11 per hour. Drivers are also paid $11 per hour, with no bonus.
60% of VF's orders are placed between 6pm and 8pm, and VF promises customers that meals will arrive within 30 minutes of leaving the kitchen. Missing this promise means VF refunds the customer.
Staff turnover in the kitchen is 40% per year, which is much higher than the industry average of 15%. The Operations Director says: "We spend all our time recruiting and training. Kitchen staff tell us the work is repetitive — they chop vegetables for an entire shift and never see a finished meal."
VF's net profit margin is 8%. The directors want to reduce staff turnover without a large increase in costs.
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to VF of paying its delivery drivers a performance-related bonus for each delivery made within 30 minutes.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of VF. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three methods VF could use to reduce the high rate of staff turnover among its kitchen staff. Which method should VF use? Justify your answer.
- •Job enrichment — let each member of kitchen staff prepare a complete meal
- •Improved fringe benefits — free meals and paid travel to work
- •A promotion scheme — create paid team-leader roles in the kitchen
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
A bonus gives drivers a financial incentive to work faster
so more meals arrive inside the 30-minute promise and VF issues fewer refunds
- Application:
Higher pay can reduce staff turnover
which matters to VF because recruiting and training is already taking up management time at 40% turnover
- Application:
A bonus rewards the most productive workers
helping VF cope with the 6pm-8pm peak when 60% of orders are placed
- Application:
Motivated drivers may give better customer service
helping VF keep customers in the three cities it operates in
- Application:
Bonuses increase labour costs
which VF can ill afford on a net profit margin of only 8%
- Application:
Drivers may rush to earn the bonus and drive dangerously
risking accidents and damage to VF's reputation, or damaged meals arriving at customers' homes
- Application:
Bonuses can be seen as unfair if delivery times are outside the driver's control
for example traffic at the 6pm-8pm peak, so some drivers are demotivated instead
- Application:
It may create resentment among staff not offered the bonus
the 25 kitchen staff are on the same $11 per hour and would receive nothing
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: A bonus gives drivers a financial incentive to work faster (1). This means more meals arrive inside VF's 30-minute promise, so VF issues fewer refunds to customers (1 app).
Advantage 2: Higher earnings can reduce staff turnover (1). This matters to VF because turnover is already a problem and managers are spending their time recruiting and training rather than running the business (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: Paying bonuses increases VF's labour costs (1). VF's net profit margin is only 8%, so the extra cost could remove much of its profit (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: Drivers may rush in order to earn the bonus (1). During the 6pm-8pm peak this could mean dangerous driving or meals arriving damaged, harming VF's reputation (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Job enrichment — let each member of kitchen staff prepare a complete meal
For
Directly addresses the cause the staff themselves gave: the work is repetitive and they never see a finished meal
Gives staff more responsibility and a sense of achievement, which Herzberg identifies as a motivator rather than a hygiene factor
Costs very little to introduce, which suits VF's 8% net profit margin
Staff who can prepare a whole meal are more flexible, helping VF cope with the 6pm-8pm peak
Against
Training 25 kitchen staff to prepare complete meals takes time and money
Output per worker may fall at first, which is risky when 60% of orders arrive in a two-hour window
Some staff may feel they are being asked to do more work for the same $11 per hour
Quality may become less consistent than with a division of labour
Improved fringe benefits — free meals and paid travel to work
For
Relatively cheap for VF because it already produces meals, so the marginal cost of a staff meal is low
Benefits are visible and immediate, so staff notice them straight away
Helps VF compete with other employers without raising the $11 hourly wage
Paid travel is valuable to staff working until after 8pm when transport is limited
Against
Does not address the actual complaint, which is that the work is repetitive
Herzberg would class benefits as a hygiene factor: they stop dissatisfaction but do not motivate
Once given, benefits are very hard to withdraw
Still adds to costs at a time when VF's net profit margin is only 8%
A promotion scheme — create paid team-leader roles in the kitchen
For
Offers a career path, giving staff a reason to stay rather than leave within the year
Meets higher-level needs in Maslow's hierarchy — esteem and self-actualisation
Team leaders can supervise the 6pm-8pm peak, improving how VF handles its busiest period
Only a few roles are created, so the cost increase is limited
Against
Only a small number of staff can be promoted, so most of the 25 remain unaffected
Staff who are not promoted may become more demotivated than before
Team leaders need training in supervision, which takes time VF's managers do not have
Does not remove the repetitive work for the majority of kitchen staff
Model recommendation
VF should introduce job enrichment.
Job enrichment is the option that addresses the stated cause of the problem. VF's own kitchen staff say the work is repetitive and that they never see a finished meal, so letting each worker prepare a complete meal removes the source of dissatisfaction rather than compensating for it. It is also the cheapest of the three, which matters on a net profit margin of 8%, and more flexible staff will help VF cope with the 6pm-8pm peak when 60% of orders arrive.
I rejected improved fringe benefits because they do not change the work itself. Free meals may stop staff complaining about pay, but the staff have told VF plainly that the problem is boredom, so turnover would be likely to continue while costs rose.
I rejected the promotion scheme because only a few of the 25 kitchen staff could become team leaders. The majority would still be chopping vegetables all shift, and those passed over could end up more demotivated than before.
This depends on VF training staff properly first, since output may dip while they learn, and that is a real risk during the two-hour peak.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to VF specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
25 kitchen staff and 12 delivery drivers
- •
wage of $11 per hour, drivers get no bonus
- •
60% of orders fall between 6pm and 8pm
- •
30-minute delivery promise, with refunds if missed
- •
kitchen staff turnover 40% against an industry average of 15%
- •
work is repetitive — staff chop vegetables all shift and never see a finished meal
- •
net profit margin is only 8%
- •
operates in three cities; set up four years ago
- •
VF is a private limited company
Examiner tip
In part (a), four of the eight marks are application marks. A point like "a bonus motivates workers" scores 1 mark and stops there; you only get the second mark by tying it to VF — the 30-minute promise, the 8% margin, the 6pm-8pm peak. In part (b), reaching the top of Level 3 requires you to say why you rejected the other two options, not just why you chose one. Most candidates discuss all three, recommend one, and then stop — which caps them around 9 marks.