Three ways to raise profit
Copper Kettle (CK)
Copper Kettle (CK) makes ceramic mugs, which it sells to gift shops for $8.00 each.
CK's fixed costs are $48 000 a month. The variable cost of each mug — clay, glaze, packaging and power — is $3.20.
CK currently produces and sells 13 500 mugs a month. Its factory can produce up to 20 000.
The owner wants to increase profit and is considering three options. She is aware that a gift shop chain buying 30% of CK's output has said it would "look elsewhere" if prices rose.
A clay supplier has offered a bulk contract that would cut the variable cost to $2.80 per mug, but CK must commit to buying 12 months of clay in advance.
A smaller industrial unit is available. It would cut fixed costs to $36 000 a month but limit output to 12 000 mugs.
CK current monthly figures (in $ unless stated)
| Value | |
|---|---|
| Selling price per mug | 8.00 |
| Variable cost per mug | 3.20 |
| Fixed costs per month | 48 000 |
| Output and sales per month (mugs) | 13 500 |
| Maximum factory capacity (mugs) | 20 000 |
Contribution per unit = selling price − variable cost per unit.
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to CK of using break-even analysis when making this decision.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of CK. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three options for increasing CK's profit. Which should CK choose? Justify your answer.
- •Raise the selling price to $9.00
- •Take the bulk clay contract, cutting variable cost to $2.80
- •Move to the smaller unit, cutting fixed costs to $36 000
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
It shows the minimum output needed to avoid a loss
CK must sell 10 000 mugs a month just to cover its costs
- Application:
It shows the margin of safety, so risk can be judged
CK's sales could fall by 3 500 mugs before it began making a loss
- Application:
It allows the effect of a change to be compared before committing
CK can compare the price rise, the cheaper clay and the smaller unit on paper first
- Application:
It assumes everything produced is sold
risky for CK if the chain taking 30% of output buys elsewhere
- Application:
It assumes costs and price stay constant at all output levels
CK's variable cost would actually fall to $2.80 with the bulk contract
- Application:
It ignores factors that cannot be measured in money
it cannot tell CK how the gift shop chain will react to a price rise
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: Break-even analysis shows the minimum output needed to avoid a loss (1). CK must sell 10 000 mugs a month — $48 000 divided by $4.80 contribution — simply to cover its costs (1 app).
Advantage 2: It shows the margin of safety (1). CK sells 13 500 mugs, so sales could fall by 3 500 before it started losing money, which tells the owner how much risk she is carrying (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: It assumes everything produced is sold (1). That is risky for CK because the chain buying 30% of its output has threatened to look elsewhere (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: It ignores factors that cannot be measured in money (1). It cannot tell CK how the gift shop chain will actually react to a price increase (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Raise the selling price to $9.00
For
Contribution rises from $4.80 to $5.80 per mug
Break-even falls from 10 000 to 8 276 mugs
If sales held at 13 500, profit would rise to $30 300
No extra cost or commitment required
Against
A chain buying 30% of output has said it would look elsewhere
Losing that chain means losing about 4 050 mugs of sales
At 9 450 mugs CK would fall below the new break-even of 8 276 only narrowly, leaving almost no margin of safety
Gift shops may not accept a 12.5% increase
Take the bulk clay contract, cutting variable cost to $2.80
For
Contribution rises from $4.80 to $5.20 per mug
Break-even falls from 10 000 to 9 231 mugs
At current sales of 13 500, profit rises to $22 200 with no price change
No customer is upset, so the chain taking 30% is unaffected
Against
CK must commit to 12 months of clay in advance
If sales fall, CK has paid for clay it cannot use
The gain is smaller than the price rise would give if demand held
Ties up cash in inventory
Move to the smaller unit, cutting fixed costs to $36 000
For
Break-even falls furthest, from 10 000 to 7 500 mugs
At current sales of 13 500, profit rises to $28 800
Lower fixed costs reduce risk if demand falls
Against
Output is capped at 12 000, below CK's current 13 500
CK would have to cut sales by 1 500 mugs, so profit is actually $21 600
All 6 500 mugs of spare capacity are lost, removing any room to grow
Moving premises is disruptive and costly
Model recommendation
CK should take the bulk clay contract.
It is the only option that raises profit without putting sales at risk. Contribution rises from $4.80 to $5.20, break-even falls from 10 000 to 9 231 mugs, and at unchanged sales of 13 500 profit rises from $16 800 to $22 200 — a gain of $5 400 a month with no customer affected.
I rejected the price rise despite its larger headline gain. It only produces $30 300 if sales hold at 13 500, and the chain taking 30% of output has said plainly it would look elsewhere. Losing it drops CK to about 9 450 mugs, barely above the new break-even of 8 276 — a far riskier position than today's 3 500-mug margin of safety.
I rejected the smaller unit because its cap of 12 000 is below CK's current output of 13 500. CK would have to turn away 1 500 mugs of existing sales, so profit is $21 600, less than the clay contract delivers, and it loses all 6 500 mugs of spare capacity.
This depends on CK's sales being stable enough to justify committing to 12 months of clay. Given a 3 500-mug margin of safety, that looks reasonable — but if the chain leaves for any other reason, CK is left holding clay it cannot use.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to CK specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
selling price $8.00 and variable cost $3.20, so contribution is $4.80 per mug
- •
fixed costs $48 000 a month give a break-even of 10 000 mugs
- •
output is 13 500 mugs, so the margin of safety is 3 500 mugs
- •
current monthly profit is $16 800
- •
capacity is 20 000 mugs, so CK has 6 500 mugs of spare capacity
- •
a chain buying 30% of output would look elsewhere if prices rose
- •
bulk clay would cut variable cost to $2.80 but needs a 12-month commitment
- •
smaller premises would cut fixed costs to $36 000 but cap output at 12 000
Examiner tip
Do the arithmetic before you argue. The smaller unit looks best on break-even alone (7 500 mugs) until you notice its 12 000 cap is below current output of 13 500 — a trap that rewards candidates who check the constraint. Remember contribution is per unit ($4.80), while total contribution is contribution × output; confusing the two is the most common calculation error on this topic.