There is a powerful case for selling. Working capital of $4 000 is dangerously thin for a business already paying its suppliers late, and $120 000 would transform that position immediately — thirty times the present figure. Selling an asset is an internal source of finance, so there is no interest to pay, nothing to repay and no share of the business surrendered, which makes it cheaper than an overdraft or a loan and available to Pritchard even if a bank would decline. It would also end the late payments, which matter more than the cash figure suggests: suppliers who are paid late withdraw credit, demand payment in advance and deprioritise deliveries, so Pritchard's present course risks losing the materials it needs to work at all. And the workshop is used only for storage, so selling it does not reduce the business's capacity to make anything.
Against that, the sale is irreversible and the workshop may be worth more than $120 000 to Pritchard than to a buyer. It is being used for storage, which is a real function — the stored materials will need to go somewhere, and renting storage space would create a permanent new expense that eats into the benefit every year. Property also tends to appreciate, so selling now may mean forgoing a rising asset and finding, if the business later expands, that premises cost far more to reacquire than they raised. The workshop is very likely the best security Pritchard has for borrowing, so selling it removes the option of a loan in future. Most importantly, the $120 000 is a one-off: if the working capital problem is caused by something ongoing — thin margins, customers paying too slowly, too much money tied up in materials — then the cash will be absorbed and the difficulty will return, with no second workshop to sell.
On balance Pritchard should sell, but only after establishing why its working capital is so low. The reasoning is that the immediate danger is severe: a business paying suppliers late is at risk of losing its supply, and that can end it within weeks, whereas the costs of selling — renting storage, forgoing appreciation, losing collateral — are all costs that can be borne over years. A business must survive the short term in order to have a long term. The asset is also genuinely under-used, which is what makes this a reasonable sale rather than the warning sign that selling a productive asset would be.
The recommendation would change if the underlying cause were identified and fixable more cheaply. If customers are simply paying slowly, offering a small discount for early payment or arranging an overdraft would relieve the pressure without permanently disposing of property, and an overdraft is the proper remedy for a timing problem. It would also change if Pritchard planned to expand into the second workshop soon, since selling it would then solve a temporary shortage by blocking the growth that would cure it permanently. So the answer turns on whether the shortage is a one-off gap or a symptom of how the business trades — and if it is the latter, selling the workshop buys time without fixing anything.