Ashton Ltd: gross profit = $400 000 − $240 000 = $160 000, a gross profit margin of 40%. Profit = $160 000 − $112 000 = $48 000, a profit margin of 12%.
Beale Ltd: gross profit = $400 000 − $280 000 = $120 000, a gross profit margin of 30%. Profit = $120 000 − $60 000 = $60 000, a profit margin of 15%.
The two businesses are the same size by revenue but reach their profit by opposite routes. Ashton trades more profitably: it keeps 40 cents in the dollar after paying for its goods, against Beale's 30, which suggests a stronger product, a better brand or the ability to charge more. That is a genuine advantage, because a business that can command a high mark-up has something its competitors do not. But Ashton is expensive to run: its expenses of $112 000 are nearly twice Beale's, and they consume 70% of its gross profit.
Beale earns less on each sale but runs itself far more cheaply, and it is the more profitable of the two where it matters — $60 000 against $48 000, a profit margin of 15% against 12%. For an investor that is the decisive comparison, because profit is what dividends are paid from. Beale's low expenses are also a source of safety: a business with a low cost base survives a downturn more easily, since Ashton must cover $112 000 of largely fixed expenses before it earns anything, and a fall in sales would hurt it much more sharply.
On these figures the investor should choose Beale Ltd, because it converts the same revenue into 25% more profit and would be more resilient if trade weakened. The reasoning rests on profit rather than on gross margin: Ashton's superior trading margin is being consumed by the cost of running the business, and an investor receives dividends out of profit, not out of gross profit.
Two things would change this. The first is the price of the shares and the capital employed in each business: if Beale's shares are expensive relative to its profit, or if Beale has twice Ashton's capital invested, then Ashton could be the better return despite the lower profit — and return on capital employed, not profit margin, is the measure an investor should use. The second is the reason for Ashton's high expenses. If they include a large one-off item, such as launching a new product or fitting out new premises, Ashton's underlying profit is better than it appears and its 40% trading margin would then make it the more attractive of the two. So my recommendation is Beale on the evidence given, but I would not commit without the capital employed figures, the share price, and a breakdown of Ashton's expenses.