Revenue up, profit down
Alba Bakery (AB)
Alba Bakery (AB) runs four shops selling bread and cakes. It employs 46 people.
AB opened its fourth shop at the start of this year. Revenue has risen, but the owner is worried that profit has fallen.
Flour and butter prices rose sharply during the year. AB did not change its selling prices, saying customers would notice.
The new fourth shop has higher rent than the others and has not yet reached the sales of the original three.
The owner says: "We sold more than ever and ended up with less. I do not understand it."
AB income statement summary (in $)
| This year | Last year | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 840 000 | 780 000 |
| Cost of sales | 520 000 | 465 000 |
| Gross profit | 320 000 | 315 000 |
| Expenses | 245 000 | 219 000 |
| Profit for the year | 75 000 | 96 000 |
Gross profit margin = gross profit ÷ revenue × 100. Profit margin = profit ÷ revenue × 100.
Explain two reasons why AB's gross profit margin has fallen and two reasons why its profit margin has fallen by more.
- Gross margin reason 1:
- Gross margin reason 2:
- Profit margin reason 1:
- Profit margin reason 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of AB. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three actions AB could take to restore its profit. Which should AB choose? Justify your answer.
- •Raise selling prices by about 5%
- •Find a cheaper flour and butter supplier
- •Close the fourth shop
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Cost of sales rose faster than revenue
AB's cost of sales rose 11.8% while revenue rose only 7.7%
- Application:
Input prices increased without a price rise to match
flour and butter prices rose sharply but AB did not change its selling prices
- Application:
Expenses rose as well as cost of sales
AB's expenses went from $219 000 to $245 000
- Application:
A new outlet adds fixed costs before it adds full revenue
AB's fourth shop has higher rent and has not yet reached the sales of the other three
- Application:
Gross profit was almost flat while expenses grew
AB's gross profit rose just $5 000 while expenses rose $26 000
Full-mark answer
Gross margin reason 1: Cost of sales rose faster than revenue (1). AB's cost of sales rose 11.8% while revenue rose only 7.7%, so the gross margin fell from 40.4% to 38.1% (1 app).
Gross margin reason 2: Input prices rose without a matching price increase (1). Flour and butter cost AB more, but it chose not to raise its selling prices (1 app).
Profit margin reason 1: Expenses rose on top of the higher cost of sales (1). AB's expenses increased from $219 000 to $245 000, a rise of $26 000 (1 app).
Profit margin reason 2: The new shop added costs before adding full revenue (1). AB's fourth shop has higher rent than the others and has not yet reached their sales levels (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Raise selling prices by about 5%
For
Directly restores the gross margin lost to higher flour and butter costs
On $840 000 of revenue, 5% is about $42 000 of extra gross profit if volumes hold
Costs nothing to implement
Against
AB believes customers would notice and may buy less
Bread and cakes have many local substitutes
If volumes fall, the gain is lost
Find a cheaper flour and butter supplier
For
Attacks the cost of sales that caused the gross margin fall
No price rise, so no risk of losing customers
A small saving is magnified: cost of sales is $520 000
Against
Cheaper ingredients may reduce quality, which matters for a bakery
Existing supplier relationships may be lost
Savings may be small if prices have risen across the whole market
Close the fourth shop
For
Removes the higher rent that helped push expenses up $26 000
Concentrates effort on the three established shops
Against
The shop is new and has not had time to build sales
Closing costs money and loses the revenue it does generate
It does nothing about the gross margin, which is a cost-of-sales problem
Staff would be made redundant from a 46-person business
Model recommendation
AB should negotiate with suppliers first, and raise prices only if that fails.
The gross margin fell from 40.4% to 38.1% because cost of sales rose 11.8% against revenue growth of 7.7%. That is an input-cost problem, so the first place to look is inputs. Cost of sales is $520 000, so even a 3% saving is about $15 600 — real money against a $75 000 profit — with no risk of losing customers.
I rejected closing the fourth shop. It opened only this year and has not had time to reach the sales of the others, so judging it now is premature, and closing it would not touch the gross margin problem at all.
I rejected an immediate price rise because AB's own judgement is that customers would notice, and bread and cakes have close substitutes. That said, if suppliers will not move, a price rise becomes necessary — AB cannot absorb rising input costs indefinitely on an 8.9% margin.
This depends on AB not damaging quality. A bakery competing on cheaper ingredients risks losing the customers it is trying to keep, so any supplier change should be tested on one product first.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to AB specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
revenue rose from $780 000 to $840 000
- •
gross profit barely moved, $315 000 to $320 000
- •
profit for the year fell from $96 000 to $75 000
- •
gross profit margin fell from 40.4% to 38.1%
- •
profit margin fell from 12.3% to 8.9%
- •
cost of sales rose from $465 000 to $520 000
- •
expenses rose from $219 000 to $245 000
- •
a fourth shop opened this year with higher rent and lower sales
- •
flour and butter prices rose; selling prices were unchanged
Examiner tip
Always calculate both margins for both years — the story is in the comparison, not the absolute figures. Here gross margin fell 2.3 percentage points but profit margin fell 3.4, which tells you expenses rose as well as costs. Note that "revenue up, profit down" is not a contradiction: revenue is not profit, and the owner's confusion is the question.