Fenwick Ltd: gross profit margin 30%, profit margin 10%, ROCE 15%, current ratio 1.5, acid test 1.0.
Garrow Ltd: gross profit margin 45%, profit margin 9%, ROCE 8%, current ratio 2.0, acid test 0.6.
Garrow wins on two measures and they are not trivial ones. Its gross profit margin of 45% against Fenwick's 30% means it earns half again as much on each dollar of sales after paying for its goods, which indicates better buying, better pricing, or a product customers value more highly — a real commercial strength, since the two are in the same industry and the comparison is therefore fair. Its current ratio of 2.0 also looks more comfortable than Fenwick's 1.5.
But Garrow converts that advantage into less profit, not more. Despite a gross margin 15 percentage points higher on identical revenue, its profit of $54 000 is below Fenwick's $60 000, which means its expenses are far larger: $216 000 against Fenwick's $120 000. Garrow earns more on every sale and spends so much more on running itself that it ends up behind. Its profit margin is accordingly slightly lower, 9% against 10%.
The decisive figure is ROCE. Fenwick earns 15% on the capital invested in it; Garrow earns 8%, little more than half as much. Garrow has $675 000 tied up in the business to produce the same revenue Fenwick produces with $400 000, so it is using its investors' money far less efficiently. And Garrow's apparently superior liquidity does not survive inspection: its current ratio is higher only because it holds $140 000 of inventory, and its acid test ratio of 0.6 is well below Fenwick's 1.0. Excluding stock, Fenwick can cover its short-term debts exactly while Garrow can cover barely three fifths of them — so on the measure that matters for paying bills quickly, Fenwick is the stronger.
Fenwick is the better-run business. The reasoning rests on ROCE and the acid test rather than on the gross margin: being well run means turning the resources invested into profit efficiently, and Fenwick produces more profit from two thirds of the capital, while also being better placed to meet its debts. Garrow's high gross margin is a genuine strength that its management is failing to convert — high expenses and a large, slow-moving stockholding are both signs of a business carrying more than it needs.
Two things would change this. If Garrow's large capital employed reflects recent investment not yet producing its full return, its ROCE could rise sharply and it might overtake Fenwick — its strong gross margin means that a business of this quality with Fenwick's cost control would be formidable. And these are single-year figures: if Fenwick's ratios are deteriorating while Garrow's improve, the trend matters more than the snapshot. I would want three years of both, and a breakdown of Garrow's expenses to see whether they are one-off or structural.