Reading two sets of ratios
Solent Retail (SR)
Solent Retail (SR) runs a chain of six homeware shops. It is comparing its performance with Marin Stores, a competitor of similar size.
SR buys well: it negotiates hard with suppliers and believes its buying is better than any rival's.
SR's shops are in prime high-street locations with high rents. It also employs more sales staff per shop than Marin does.
A shareholder has asked why SR's return is lower than Marin's when SR "buys better and sells more".
Comparison of key figures and ratios (in $ unless stated)
| Solent Retail | Marin Stores | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 1 250 000 | 1 180 000 |
| Gross profit | 425 000 | 365 800 |
| Profit for the year | 112 500 | 129 800 |
| Capital employed | 750 000 | 683 000 |
| Gross profit margin | 34% | 31% |
| Profit margin | 9% | 11% |
| Return on capital employed | 15% | 19% |
| Current ratio | 1.3 | 1.8 |
| Acid test ratio | 0.6 | 1.1 |
Explain two conclusions about SR's profitability and two conclusions about its liquidity that can be drawn from these ratios.
- Profitability conclusion 1:
- Profitability conclusion 2:
- Liquidity conclusion 1:
- Liquidity conclusion 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of SR. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three actions SR could take to improve its return on capital employed. Which should SR choose? Justify your answer.
- •Reduce the number of sales staff per shop
- •Move some shops from prime high-street sites to cheaper locations
- •Raise prices to lift the gross margin further
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
A higher gross margin shows better buying or pricing
SR's 34% beats Marin's 31%, consistent with SR negotiating hard with suppliers
- Application:
A lower profit margin despite a higher gross margin means expenses are too high
SR's margin falls from 34% to 9%, a gap of 25 percentage points, or $312 500 of expenses
- Application:
Lower ROCE means capital is being used less efficiently
SR returns 15% on capital employed against Marin's 19%
- Application:
A lower current ratio means less cover for short-term debts
SR's 1.3 is well below Marin's 1.8
- Application:
A low acid test shows dependence on selling inventory
SR's 0.6 means it could cover only 60% of short-term debts without selling stock, against Marin's 1.1
Full-mark answer
Profitability conclusion 1: SR buys or prices better than Marin (1). Its gross profit margin is 34% against Marin's 31%, which fits SR's claim that it negotiates hard with suppliers (1 app).
Profitability conclusion 2: SR's expenses are too high (1). Its margin falls from 34% to 9% — a gap of 25 percentage points, or $312 500 — because of prime-location rents and extra sales staff (1 app).
Liquidity conclusion 1: SR has less cover for its short-term debts (1). Its current ratio of 1.3 is well below Marin's 1.8 (1 app).
Liquidity conclusion 2: SR depends on selling inventory to pay its debts (1). Its acid test of 0.6 means it could cover only 60% of short-term liabilities without selling stock, against Marin's 1.1 (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Reduce the number of sales staff per shop
For
Attacks the expenses that turn a 34% gross margin into a 9% profit margin
Wages are a large, controllable expense within the $312 500
Can be done gradually through natural turnover
Against
Service quality may fall, and homeware customers often want advice
Could reduce sales, worsening rather than improving the margin
Damages staff morale across six shops
Move some shops from prime high-street sites to cheaper locations
For
Rent is the other major expense behind the 25-point gap
Lower capital employed would raise ROCE directly
Marin achieves 19% ROCE without prime sites
Against
Prime locations bring footfall; SR's revenue is higher than Marin's
Moving costs money and disrupts trade
SR could lose the passing customers that support its $1 250 000 revenue
Raise prices to lift the gross margin further
For
SR already buys well, so a price rise would go straight to gross profit
No change to the cost base is required
Against
SR's gross margin at 34% is already above Marin's 31% — this is not the weakness
Higher prices risk losing the sales volume that gives SR higher revenue
Does nothing about the $312 500 of expenses that actually cause the problem
Model recommendation
SR should review its shop locations, moving the weakest-performing sites to cheaper premises.
The ratios locate the problem precisely. SR is not bad at buying — its 34% gross margin beats Marin's 31%. The failure happens between gross and net: 25 percentage points, $312 500, disappear into expenses, and the case names prime-location rent as a main cause. Moving the weakest sites cuts that expense and lowers capital employed, which raises ROCE from both directions.
I rejected raising prices because it improves the one ratio SR is already winning on. A firm with a better gross margin and a worse profit margin has a cost problem, not a pricing problem.
I rejected cutting sales staff as the first move. It targets the right line but risks the revenue advantage SR currently holds — SR sells more than Marin, and in homeware that may be precisely because staff are on hand to advise.
This depends on SR identifying which shops genuinely depend on footfall. Prime sites that justify their rent should stay; the recommendation is to move the ones that do not, which requires shop-by-shop figures the case does not give. SR should also address the 0.6 acid test, since weak liquidity limits its options either way.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to SR specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
SR's gross profit margin is 34% against Marin's 31%
- •
SR's profit margin is 9% against Marin's 11%
- •
SR's ROCE is 15% against Marin's 19%
- •
SR's expenses are $312 500, which is 25% of revenue
- •
SR's current ratio is 1.3 against Marin's 1.8
- •
SR's acid test is 0.6 against Marin's 1.1
- •
SR has prime high-street locations with high rents
- •
SR employs more sales staff per shop than Marin
- •
SR's revenue is higher than Marin's at $1 250 000
Examiner tip
Ratios mean more in combination than alone. Higher gross margin plus lower profit margin can only mean expenses, and saying so is the analysis mark. Always compare like with like — both firms here are a similar size, which is what makes the comparison fair — and remember ROCE is the ratio that matters most to an investor, because it measures return against money invested.