Pay the fine, or fix the problem?
Willow Paper (WP)
Willow Paper (WP) runs a paper mill employing 260 people in a small town. It is the town's largest employer.
WP discharges treated water into the river beside the mill. Recent tests showed the discharge is within the legal limit, but close to it.
A local campaign group has published photographs of discoloured water and organised a petition signed by 3 400 residents.
A new treatment plant would cut the discharge by about 90% and cost $850 000, plus $60 000 a year to run.
If the legal limit were tightened — which the government is consulting on — WP could face fines of about $40 000 a year, or be ordered to close for a period.
Two of WP's largest customers, who print packaging for food brands, have asked WP to complete an environmental questionnaire. Together they provide 45% of WP's revenue of $9.2 million.
WP's operations director says: "We are within the law. Nobody can make us spend $850 000."
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to WP of investing in the new water treatment plant.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of WP. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three courses of action for WP. Which should WP choose? Justify your answer.
- •Do nothing — WP is within the law
- •Budget for the $40 000 annual fines if limits tighten
- •Install the treatment plant
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
It protects the firm against future changes in the law
the government is consulting on tightening limits, and WP is already close to the current one
- Application:
It protects relationships with environmentally conscious customers
two of WP's customers providing 45% of $9.2 million revenue have sent an environmental questionnaire
- Application:
It improves reputation with the local community
3 400 residents have signed a petition against WP
- Application:
The capital cost is high
WP must find $850 000 up front
- Application:
Running costs reduce profit every year
the plant would cost WP a further $60 000 a year to operate
- Application:
The spending is not legally required
WP's discharge is currently within the legal limit, as the operations director points out
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: It protects WP against future changes in the law (1). The government is consulting on tightening the limit, and WP's discharge is already close to the current one (1 app).
Advantage 2: It protects key customer relationships (1). Two of WP's customers, providing 45% of its $9.2 million revenue, have asked it to complete an environmental questionnaire (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: The capital cost is high (1). WP would have to find $850 000 before the plant produced any benefit (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: Running costs reduce profit every year (1). The plant would cost WP an extra $60 000 a year to operate (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Do nothing — WP is within the law
For
No cost at all, protecting short-term profit
The discharge is legal, as the operations director says
Avoids committing $850 000 before the consultation concludes
Against
Ignores a petition signed by 3 400 residents in a town where WP is the largest employer
Risks the environmental questionnaire from customers worth $4.14 million of revenue
If limits tighten, WP faces fines or a forced closure with no plan ready
Being legal is not the same as being acceptable to customers
Budget for the $40 000 annual fines if limits tighten
For
Far cheaper than $850 000 — about 21 years of fines for the same money
Keeps cash available for other uses
No disruption to production
Against
Fines are not the only risk: WP could be ordered to close for a period
Paying fines to keep polluting is exactly what the questionnaire is designed to find
Does nothing for the community relationship
A closure order would cost far more than $850 000 in lost output
Install the treatment plant
For
Cuts discharge by about 90%, removing the regulatory risk entirely
Gives WP a strong answer to the customers' questionnaire
Addresses the residents' petition in the town where WP employs 260 people
Protects $4.14 million of revenue for $850 000 plus $60 000 a year
Against
$850 000 is a large sum WP is not legally obliged to spend
$60 000 a year permanently reduces profit
The government consultation may come to nothing
Money spent here cannot be invested elsewhere
Model recommendation
WP should install the treatment plant.
The operations director is right that nobody can force WP to spend $850 000, and that is the wrong test. Two customers worth about $4.14 million of revenue — 45% of $9.2 million — are actively auditing WP's environmental performance. Losing either would cost several times the price of the plant, so this is a commercial decision before it is an ethical one.
The regulatory position points the same way. WP is already close to the current limit while the government consults on tightening it, so the choice is between installing the plant now, in a planned way, or being ordered to do it later under pressure.
I rejected doing nothing because it treats legality as the only standard, while the real risks — customers and a possible closure order — sit outside the law.
I rejected budgeting for fines. $40 000 a year looks cheap against $850 000, but it misses that fines are not the worst outcome: a temporary closure order would cost far more, and deliberately paying to keep polluting is precisely what the questionnaire would expose.
This depends on WP being able to fund $850 000. If it cannot, it should commit publicly to a timetable and begin discussions with both customers now, rather than waiting to be asked.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to WP specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
260 employees; WP is the town's largest employer
- •
the discharge is within the legal limit but close to it
- •
a petition signed by 3 400 residents
- •
a treatment plant costs $850 000 plus $60 000 a year to run
- •
potential fines are about $40 000 a year if limits tighten
- •
two customers providing 45% of $9.2 million revenue have sent an environmental questionnaire
- •
45% of $9.2 million is about $4.14 million of revenue at risk
- •
the government is consulting on tightening the limit
Examiner tip
The strongest answers treat ethics and commerce together rather than as opposites. Here the ethical action is also the profitable one because $4.14 million of revenue is being audited — say that explicitly. Watch the trap in "we are within the law": legal compliance is a minimum, not a defence against customers or a community of 3 400 petitioners.