There is a strong case for expanding. A recession makes everything a business needs to expand cheaper: shop premises stand empty so rents and purchase prices fall and landlords offer better terms, equipment can be bought second-hand from firms that have closed, and skilled staff are available who would be unobtainable in a boom. Two of Ravensworth's competitors have already closed, so their customers are looking for somewhere else to buy bread — demand has not disappeared, it has been released. Ravensworth is also unusually well placed to act: it is profitable and holds a large cash reserve, so it can fund expansion without borrowing at a time when banks are cautious and expensive. Bread is close to a necessity, which means the fall in its demand during a recession is far smaller than for most products.
Against that, expanding into a recession carries real risk. The recession may deepen or last longer than expected, and four new shops bring fixed costs — rent, staff, utilities — that continue whether or not the shops are busy. Spending the cash reserve removes the very protection that has allowed Ravensworth to survive while its competitors failed, and it is that reserve which lets a business ride out a downturn. Four shops at once is also a substantial management burden: recruiting, training and supervising four new teams while trading conditions are difficult stretches managers who are already busy. And the competitors may have closed because the market cannot support as many bakeries as it did, in which case the released demand is smaller than it appears.
Ravensworth should expand, but by opening two shops rather than four. The reasoning is that a recession genuinely is the cheapest time to acquire premises and staff, and its competitors' closure has handed it an opportunity that will not last — when the economy recovers, new competitors will open and rents will rise. But the case for expanding does not require expanding at the maximum rate. Two shops capture much of the opportunity while leaving a substantial cash reserve intact and keeping the management task manageable, and the remaining two can follow once the first two are trading well.
The recommendation would change if bread in this area were genuinely in oversupply, since then the closures reflect a shrinking market rather than weak rivals, and no amount of cheap rent makes an unwanted shop profitable. It would also change if the cash reserve were needed for something else — a loan repayment falling due, or ageing equipment requiring replacement. So my answer depends on why the competitors closed, which the directors should establish before committing anything.