Responding to rising interest rates
Horizon Homes (HH)
Horizon Homes (HH) builds and sells family houses. It employs 210 people and completed 96 houses last year at an average price of $185 000.
The central bank has raised interest rates from 4% to 7% to reduce inflation, which is currently 9%.
Most of HH's customers buy with a mortgage. Enquiries have fallen by 40% since the rate rise, and HH has 14 completed houses unsold.
HH has a $3.2 million variable-rate loan. The rate rise adds about $96 000 a year to its interest cost.
Building material costs have risen 12% in a year, while HH's selling prices have not changed.
The finance director says: "We are being squeezed at both ends — our costs are up and our customers cannot borrow."
Explain two ways rising interest rates increase HH's costs and two ways they reduce HH's revenue.
- Cost effect 1:
- Cost effect 2:
- Revenue effect 1:
- Revenue effect 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of HH. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three responses HH could make. Which should HH choose? Justify your answer.
- •Cut the price of the 14 unsold houses
- •Reduce output and delay starting new houses
- •Switch the $3.2 million loan to a fixed rate
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Interest on existing variable-rate borrowing rises
HH's $3.2 million loan costs about $96 000 a year more after the rise from 4% to 7%
- Application:
New borrowing becomes more expensive
HH would pay more to finance building the next set of houses
- Application:
Suppliers facing higher borrowing costs may raise prices
HH's material costs are already up 12% in a year
- Application:
Customers find mortgages more expensive, so demand falls
HH's enquiries have fallen 40% since the rate rise
- Application:
Fewer sales means stock is unsold and revenue is delayed
HH has 14 completed houses standing unsold
- Application:
The firm may have to cut prices to sell
HH may not be able to hold its $185 000 average price with demand down 40%
Full-mark answer
Cost effect 1: Interest on existing variable-rate borrowing rises (1). HH's $3.2 million loan now costs about $96 000 a year more after rates went from 4% to 7% (1 app).
Cost effect 2: Suppliers facing higher borrowing costs pass them on (1). HH's building material costs have already risen 12% in a year (1 app).
Revenue effect 1: Customers find mortgages more expensive, so demand falls (1). Most of HH's buyers use a mortgage, and enquiries have dropped 40% since the rise (1 app).
Revenue effect 2: Unsold stock delays revenue (1). HH has 14 completed houses standing unsold, tying up cash it has already spent building them (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Cut the price of the 14 unsold houses
For
Releases cash tied up in completed stock quickly
Helps buyers who can now borrow less because of 7% rates
Reduces the risk of holding houses that may fall further in value
Against
Lower revenue on each house against a $185 000 average
Earlier buyers may feel unfairly treated
Sets an expectation of discounts for future buyers
Does nothing about the $96 000 of extra interest
Reduce output and delay starting new houses
For
Avoids building more houses into a market where enquiries are down 40%
Reduces the need for new borrowing at 7%
Stops HH adding to the 14 already unsold
Against
Some of the 210 employees would have little to do, or face redundancy
Skilled workers lost now are hard to replace when demand recovers
Fixed costs continue even with lower output
HH loses sales entirely if the market recovers sooner than expected
Switch the $3.2 million loan to a fixed rate
For
Makes interest costs predictable, which helps planning
Protects HH if rates rise further from 7%
Directly addresses the $96 000 cost increase
Against
Fixed rates are usually set above current variable rates, so costs may rise again immediately
HH gains nothing if rates fall back
There may be a fee to switch
Does nothing about the 40% fall in enquiries, which is the bigger problem
Model recommendation
HH should cut the price of the 14 unsold houses.
HH's most urgent problem is cash, not cost. It has already spent the money building 14 houses that are earning nothing, and with enquiries down 40% they may not sell at $185 000 for some time. Releasing that cash lets HH meet the extra $96 000 of interest without new borrowing at 7%.
I rejected cutting output as the first move because it is hard to reverse. Losing skilled workers from a 210-strong workforce means HH cannot restart quickly when rates fall, and rates are being raised to control 9% inflation, so the squeeze may be temporary.
I rejected switching to a fixed rate because it addresses the smaller problem. The $96 000 of extra interest matters, but the 40% fall in enquiries is what threatens the business, and a fixed rate does nothing about that — it may even raise costs further, since fixed rates usually sit above variable ones.
This depends on how far HH has to cut. If the discount needed is so large that HH sells at a loss, it would be better to hold the houses and slow production instead — so HH should set a floor price based on build cost before it starts discounting.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to HH specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
210 employees; 96 houses completed last year at an average $185 000
- •
interest rates have risen from 4% to 7%
- •
inflation is currently 9%
- •
enquiries have fallen 40% since the rate rise
- •
14 completed houses are unsold
- •
HH has a $3.2 million variable-rate loan
- •
the rate rise adds about $96 000 a year to interest costs
- •
material costs are up 12% while selling prices are unchanged
- •
most customers buy with a mortgage
Examiner tip
Interest rate questions have two sides: the firm's own borrowing costs and its customers' ability to borrow. For HH the customer side is far larger — a 40% fall in enquiries dwarfs $96 000 of interest — and saying which matters more is the evaluation. Note also that high inflation with falling demand squeezes from both directions, which is exactly what the finance director describes.